MPH: Sainz finally has an F1 team to lead. Is it worth dropping so far down the grid?

F1

Carlos Sainz has battled against 'chosen' team-mates like Max Verstappen and Charles Leclerc for all his F1 career — and thrived. Now, at Williams, he finally has a team centred on him, says Mark Hughes. But the fight goes on

Carlos Sainz in cockpit of Williams F1 car at Abu Dhabi post season test

Two days after finishing on the podium for Ferrari, Carlos Sainz was in the Williams for the post-season Abu Dhabi test

Getty Images

Mark Hughes

Carlos Sainz did his first laps in a Williams the day after the Abu Dhabi Grand Prix. Throughout the race weekend he was “trying to memorise how the [Ferrari] feels because I need to remember why this car is quick.” At the end of the test day in the Williams he will surely have been reflecting upon just how big the gap is between the Ferrari SF-24 he’s raced this year and the FW46 – and about how long it may take for the team to bridge a gap of around 1sec per lap. Doesn’t sound much, but it’s the difference between being near the front and near the back.

As for why Carlos should be in this situation after delivering the way he has in his time at Maranello, he’s well past that. He claims he was past it even before the season started but admits feelings of hurt, anger and bewilderment when he was first told Lewis Hamilton would be replacing him.

In his recent Beyond the Grid interview for F1 he explained how he understood immediately, but it took a little time to get past the shock. “When Lewis Hamilton, one of the best in history, if not the best, is going to replace you to do his final years at Ferrari, I understand,” he said. “I also understand it was never going to be Charles [Leclerc] who would be released. He’s been their project since he was a junior. I arrived through circumstances, as a sort of Vettel replacement.”

Carlos Sainz and Charles LEclerc battle in 2024 F1 US Grand Prix

Sainz vs Leclerc in this year’s US GP: their friendly competitiveness helped get the most out of the Ferrari

Ferrari

That, right there, is the crucial point about Sainz’s career so far: he has always been half-a-step behind in how he’s been perceived, always seeking to prove he can go up against anyone. He’s never had the empowerment of being the targeted one around whom a team is built. Yet he’s superbly well equipped to be that. But he’s had to go a long way down the grid to get that empowerment.

If we look at his F1 career, he was brought into the junior Red Bull team as a rookie at the same time as Max Verstappen. But it was under very different terms. Helmut Marko had been trying to enlist the Verstappens for years, believing – correctly – that Max was a generational talent. Marko did not initially show much interest in bringing Sainz – a well-established and successful member of the Red Bull junior driver programme, a title winner in Formula Renault and Renault 3.5 – in alongside. With some work behind the scenes by Carlos Sainz Sr (he talked with Dietrich Mateschitz and Christian Horner), Sainz was offered a test at Silverstone in 2013 in the Red Bull. He lapped it faster than Sebastian Vettel’s best time in the Grand Prix there. Even Marko was impressed and ultimately that sealed Carlos’s place there.

Related article

So he got the drive but the impetus was always with the wunderkind Verstappen, who even had it in his contract that unless he was moved up into the senior team by a specified date, he’d be free to go elsewhere. Extraordinary terms for a rookie, but that’s the value of empowerment. It comes from the perception of being something beyond the norm and no matter how well Sainz did, he would always be fighting that. In their time together at Toro Rosso, Verstappen scored more points, but Sainz was actually marginally faster in qualifying, as an average. The gap in comparable sessions was 0.136% in Sainz’s favour in 2015 and 0.075% in the first four races of 2016 in which they were team-mates. By any objective measure, they were extremely closely-matched. But that was not the general perception. Empowerment and perception carries its own momentum and only adds performance.

Sainz remained in the junior team but after a couple of seasons with no place available in the senior squad, he successfully campaigned to be released to take up an offer at Renault. It was circumstantial in that the team already had Nico Hülkenberg as its big money driver but needed the second car to be scoring points more frequently than Jolyon Palmer had managed. He had his moments there, but Hülkenberg had the upper hand. McLaren recruited him as Fernando Alonso’s replacement, another circumstantial move. Once there, he had the edge over McLaren’s star rookie Lando Norris. Not always, but over their two seasons together Sainz was ahead, their partnership super-competitive but very good natured.

“Sainz and Leclerc were incredible in how hard they were pushing each other”

Ferrari boss Mattia Binotto liked that aspect of what he saw in Sainz; competitive, capable of scoring heavily, but intelligent and with a civilised personality which wouldn’t cause waves in a team which was centred around its chosen one: Leclerc. Sebastian Vettel, as a proud four-time world champion, could never be in that support role to a junior. The dynamic was just wrong – and that’s why he was let go. Vettel too had suffered a loss of empowerment. He’d been recruited by Luca di Montezemolo, on the recommendation of Michael Schumacher, to be the new Schumacher, the man to lead the team into its next phase of glory. But di Montezemolo was gone by the time Seb arrived and the new management did not share his vision of why Vettel was that man, almost challenging him to prove it to them every weekend.

Sainz fitted into his new role, understanding the circumstances but not intending to be anyone’s support driver. He’d compete – hard. And that’s how it’s been. Leclerc, arguably the fastest driver on the grid over a single lap, qualified an average of 0.037sec faster than Sainz this year. They’ve fought over track space regularly for four years and never quite touched. They’ve had their moments of competitive niggle, but it’s never been poisoned, always easily defused.

“I have never in all my time of racing seen two team-mates so intensely preoccupied with what the other one is doing,” says Ferrari’s boss Frederic Vasseur. “They were incredible in how hard they were pushing each other – out of the car too, in how much work they were putting in. I really believe that competitive fight between them has brought us performance.”

Overhead view of Carlos Sainz in Williams for 2024 Abu Dhabi post season test

Williams was ninth in this year’s constructors’ championship: Sainz faces a battle to get back to the front

Grand Prix Photo

That’s what Sainz brings to a team – and this year adversity has seemed to bring even more from him. That Melbourne victory just days after leaving his hospital bed from his appendectomy was incredible. His dominance of Mexico after ambushing a pass on Verstappen, was from the absolute top drawer.

Well, his task at Williams sees him facing more adversity. But he’s now empowered – as the multiple grand prix winner who is going to help them fight their way up the grid. It’s going to be fascinating to watch.