Piastri's made a stronger start to F1 career than Hamilton did — by one key stat

F1

Oscar Piastri has apparently been shaded so far by McLaren F1 team-mate Lando Norris, but Tony Dodgins writes that the qualifying numbers tell a different story

2 2023 Saudi Arabian GP OSCAR PIASTRI MCLAREN

Piastri has acquitted himself well so far against McLaren team-mate Norris

Grand Prix Photo

Last weekend’s Spanish GP was a weekend of surprises.

The first one came courtesy of McLaren team principal Andrea Stella. We all know that the Red Bull RB19 is on another level but Stella wasn’t ashamed to both admit it and to doff his cap.

Talking about the moment that Sergio Perez’s car was craned high and handsome in Monaco after Sergio shunted it, Stella admitted that McLaren had studied the car’s underbody in intense detail.

“Myself, I spent some time, but the 100 aerodynamicists at McLaren will be spending a little bit more!” he said with a wry smile. “It’s very interesting indeed and shows the complexity and quality of their development. To be honest, when I saw it, I said hats off! I can understand why they have this kind of performance…”

2 2023 Spanish GP OSCAR PIASTRI MCLAREN

Piastri’s qualifying margin to Norris has been surprisingly close

Grand Prix Photo

So, if you can’t beat ‘em, join ‘em. Or at least have them join you. Which is what McLaren has done in poaching Red Bull’s 55-year-old chief engineering officer Rob Marshall, who has 17 years’ experience at Milton Keynes. Gardening leave means that Marshall will start work at McLaren on Jan 1, 2024, the same day that Ferrari’s David Sanchez also returns to Woking.

Stella said in Barcelona, “Rob will join us with a unique level of experience and engineering know-how and has been instrumental in the strong technical department that exists at Red Bull. He was keen to join and understands our ambition and that he can be fundamentally important. Red Bull knows his involvement over time and it evokes respect. I saw it from the outside, from Red Bull to Rob.”

Lando Norris and Oscar Piastri will be hoping that the strengthened technical line-up can elevate them into front-running contenders. The current car has somewhat masked the highly impressive start to the season made by the Australian rookie.

From the archive

Many predicted that Piastri, with pretty much a year out of the cockpit, would have his work cut-out against Norris but, coming into last weekend, although Norris led their qualifying head-to-head 5-1, the delta between the pair over the opening six races was actually the closest across the entire grid, at just 0.07sec.

Okay, it’s skewed slightly by Norris’s Q1 clipping of the wall in Jeddah, but even so that’s impressive from Piastri. Monaco, in particular, underlined it when Oscar sensibly built up to it over the weekend before ultimately qualifying within a couple of hundredths of Lando, then raced impressively too.

Over at AlphaTauri, Nyck De Vries is also 5-1 down against Yuki Tsunoda, the delta there being 0.26sec. Talking about that in Spain, team boss Franz Tost articulated just how tough the early season is for rookies: “It’s difficult for them to learn fast because some of the tracks – Saudi, Melbourne, Miami – they don’t even know. And it’s even tougher if the car’s not performing well.” Nobody seems to have told Piastri.

It prompted me to think back to the last time a rookie with junior credentials as strong as Piastri’s came into F1 against a recognised front-runner. That was Lewis Hamilton against Fernando Alonso in ’07 when, in deep contrast to the present, there was almost limitless between-race testing. For the record, after six races Lewis was 4-2 down versus Fernando, with an average qualifying deficit of 0.13sec, so Oscar is doing just fine!

2 2007 Japanese GP Lewis Hamilton MCLAREN

Hamilton was also close on qualifying speed to his McLaren team-mate Alonso in debut year – but not as close as Piastri to Norris

Grand Prix Photo

But, bursting the bubble a bit, the reason the two McLarens were the quickest cars on the track in the wet phase of the Monte Carlo race, had its root in their ability to generate tyre temperature and hence grip, a familiar McLaren trait these past few seasons. It was the same characteristic that allowed Norris to get the tyres in and qualify on the second row in Barcelona with hard compound rubber and low track temperature. McLaren fans shouldn’t get too excited just yet. It was conditions-specific, didn’t translate in the race and is unlikely to repeat in forthcoming races, although Montreal can be a bit nippy.

This weekend in Montreal though should give a much clearer picture of whether teams’ respective technical changes have worked and what the current competitive order is.

The Mercedes pace from its upgraded W14 was another surprise, the car comprehensively outpacing Aston Martin and Ferrari in the race. George Russell was one of those who didn’t get his tyres in during qualifying but drove a fabulous race to finish on the podium behind the peerless Verstappen and yteam mate Hamilton. Coming into the weekend, George was targeting runner-up spot in the constructors’ championship, which is where Toto Wolff’s troops now find themselves. But, before action began, Russell was cautioning against reading too much into Barcelona. Remember last year, he pointed out, when he’d finished on the podium while Lewis drove a ballistic race from the back after a puncture. They left thinking they’d cracked it, but were wrong.

All that said, if Mercedes is once again heading the Red Bull chase in Montreal, you’re likely to see much bigger smiles on the drivers and crew.