The fallout from 2021 Abu Dhabi GP — what changed in F1... and what didn't

F1

It should have been a showcase for Formula 1, but the 2021 Abu Dhabi Grand Prix title decider turned into a farce. Plenty has changed following the event, but issues — and rivalries remain

Lewis Hamilton ahead of Max Verstappen in practice for the 2021 Abu Dhabi Grand Prix

Giuseppe Cacace/AFP via Getty Images

It has been a two years since the 2021 Abu Dhabi Grand Prix — from the few frantic minutes when the drivers’ championship was decided amid the wails of Toto Wolff, the snippy retorts of race director Michael Masi, the urgings of Christian Horner and Mercedes’ standby lawyer swinging into action.

Even now, more than 40 races races later, the bitter after-effects represent a wound that Formula 1 still cannot heal. Suspicion, mistrust and sheer disappointment continue to surround the moments where Lewis Hamilton lost out to Max Verstappen in a race — and title decider — that he had until then looked his for the taking.

Ahead of the 2023 race, Wolff harked backed to the safety car-related scandal, as he spoke about this year’s fight with Ferrari. “We’re going there pretty much equal on points, with a proper race director, so that should be fine,” he said.

F1’s governing body, the FIA, has been walking on eggshells since, and acutely aware of any accusations of favouritism. Last year’s prize-giving ceremony, where the championship trophies were handed out, should have been a moment for celebration but, when FIA president Mohammed ben Sulayem handed the constructors’ prize to Red Bull boss Christian Horner, he began talking about the series’ cost cap — which Red Bull had controversially breached — then defended his officials’ actions over a points mix-up at the Japanese Grand Prix. F1 CEO Stefano Domenicali had to intervene to get the night back on track.

Abu Dhabi dominated the first year of Ben Sulayem’s period in office, having been voted in five days after the controversial season finale, and although much has changed but many issues remain, as we explore below.

The story of the Grand Prix, where either Verstappen or Hamilton would have been worthy winners, is one that nobody who watched will need reminding of. Until the late safety car, Hamilton had the lead and the better performance over the course of the race. He was destined for a record-breaking eighth championship.

But when the safety car bunched up the field at the end of the race, to allow marshals to clear the wreckage of Nicholas Latifi’s crashed Williams, Hamilton was vulnerable on old tyres — unable to pit without losing position — while Verstappen, directly behind, had been able to fit new tyres and retain second.

However, there weren’t enough laps to follow the usual restart procedure before the chequered flag. Ordinarily in that scenario, the race would finish behind the safety car; there would be no opportunity to overtake; and Hamilton would have been champion.

That didn’t happen. Masi ordered a shorter procedure in an unprecedented decision that allowed a final lap of racing. Wolff’s cry of “No Michael!” over the radio said everything. Given Hamilton’s deteriorating tyres, the result was all but inevitable and, on the final lap, Verstappen duly swept past to victory in the race and championship.

Here is how Formula 1 has changed since the Abu Dhabi debacle.

 

Safety car procedure

Safety car leads Lewis Hamilton in the 2021 Abu Dhabi GP

The safety car call ultimately deposed Hamilton from his championship-winning position

Lars Baron/Getty Images

Ultimately, Masi took the wrong decision. Teams had previously told him that they were keen to avoid finishing under a safety car wherever possible, but the rules were not written with his course of action in mind.

Related article

However, the FIA’s investigation conceded that there was a grey area where the rules could be interpreted as giving Masi free rein to adjust the procedure, which he did by allowing only some lapped cars to unlap themselves so the race could be restarted quicker — with only the leading cars in position order rather than the full grid — and then immediately ordering the safety car in, instead of allowing the lapped cars to catch the pack up.

The rules have now been rewritten to remove that ambiguity.

Grey areas

22 TSUNODA Yuki (jap), Scuderia AlphaTauri Honda AT02, action, during the Formula 1 Emirates Grand Prix de France 2021, 7th round of the 2021 FIA Formula One World Championship from June 18 to 20, 2021 on the Circuit Paul Ricard, in Le Castellet, France - Photo Marc de Mattia / DPPI

Track limits were clearer in 2022

Marc de Mattia / DPPI

The safety car procedure wasn’t the only part of the regulations that has been clarified since the Abu Dhabi race. It might be impossible to legislate for every eventuality, but 2021 saw the same issues resurfacing time and time again.

Exceeding track limits was the big one. F1 had seemingly slipped into a vague system where drivers weren’t allowed to cut some corners on some tracks, but could run as far off the circuit as they wanted on others, even where there appeared to be an advantage in doing so.

To popular acclaim, the white line at the margin of the circuit was reinstated as the edge and any driver putting all four wheels over the line is liable to have their lap deleted.

That has led to unpopular in-race penalties when drivers have repeatedly exceeded track limits, as well as qualifying laps deleted: at the 2023 Qatar Grand Prix, Lando Norris set two times in the final Q3 session, which were good enough to put him second on the grid. But he went over the white lines on both occasions and had to start 10th.

Related article

‘FIA is still making the same mistakes that got Masi fired’: Medland
F1

'FIA is still making the same mistakes that got Masi fired': Medland

What has changed since last year's Abu Dhabi controversy? Michael Masi was sacked as F1 race director for inconsistently applying the rules, but Alpine's penalty at the US GP shows that the FIA is still suffering the same problem, writes Chris Medland

By Chris Medland

However, the conundrum that drove the decisions in Abu Dhabi still remains: should races finish under the safety car?

Italian fans were denied the prospect of seeing Charles Leclerc making a last-ditch bid for the race win in Monza, 2022, when the cars processed over the finish line, still under safety car conditions, as marshals cleared the broken-down McLaren of Daniel Ricciardo.

There were plenty who thought that a red flag followed by a restart would be an apt way to finish the race.

But the 2023 Australian Grand Prix showed the dramatic downsides of stopping a race and then restarting it. Firstly a red flag in the early stages of the race ruined the strategies of some drivers who had already made their pitstop, as teams are allowed to change tyres and repair damage when a race is halted, without losing any position.

Then with four laps to go, Kevin Magnussen crashed. A safety car initially came out, then the red flag was waved. With two laps remaining, the race resumed from a standing start with predictable mayhem. Turn 1 offered the opportunity for enormous gains, followed by a short sprint to the flag and so drivers gambled en masse, piled into the first corner, and the resulting crashed left right and centre saw another red flag. The race finished behind the safety car.

 

Passing off track

Lewis Hamilton runs wide past Max Verstappen at the 2021 Abu Dhabi Grand Prix

Hamilton went off-track as Verstappen lunged down the inside of Turn 6

Joe Portlock/F1 via Getty Images

Before the Abu Dhabi safety car, the race’s big controversy came about when Hamilton fended off Verstappen early in the Abu Dhabi race by cutting a corner.

He slowed to allow the Red Bull driver to catch him up but didn’t have to give the place back. It followed previous incidents in Saudi Arabia where teams were seen to have negotiated with the race director in order to avoid a penalty for running off track.

This was supposed to be resolved in 2022 when teams would have to decide whether to give back places without any intervention from race control. If they kept an advantage by running off track, then they would risk a penalty.

However, this seems to have broken down. Over the season, Mercedes and Red Bull told their drivers to give places back after a message from race control.

 

No team radio

Michael Masi (FIA) before the 2020 Australian Grand Prix in Albert Park, Melbourne. Photo: Grand Prix Photo

Masi had to field pitwall complaints during races

Grand Prix Photo

Verstappen and Hamilton in glorious battle provided the visuals for 2021, but let’s not forget that the soundtrack was more often than not team principals whining to Masi about how their rivals had barely crossed a white line / rubbed tyres / not left enough room / had done something to offend somebody else in this notoriously sensitive sport.

It was the first year that these distracting messages to the race director had been broadcast — and the last. Pitwalls trying to dictate the rules to race control in Abu Dhabi had to be the final straw.

Unfortunately, officials — no longer the race director —  still have to listen to the grumbles. Happily, none of us do any more and that is probably a good thing for the sport.

 

Remote race control

Officials in F1 remote operations centre during 2022 Azerbaijan GP

Officials see everything in remote race control but limit communication with race control

FIA via Twitter

With the race director under fire, it’s unsurprising that Ben Sulayem leapt upon a suggestion for an F1 version of football’s VAR: more pairs of eyes that could analyse and assist with complicated and controversial decisions, taking more pressure off the race director.

Related article

And so a new operations centre was set up in Geneva, with access to the same race feeds. It hasn’t quite panned out as billed though, which isn’t entirely surprising because it wasn’t very clear why a VAR system was needed: it’s not like in football where everyone has to stop and wait for a decision

The Swiss team is in touch with race control over grand prix weekends, helping to spot issues and analyse incidents but can’t overturn decisions.

But it may turn out to be more significant away from race weekends, where there are plans to use it to stage virtual race weekends. Officials and race directors will be able to simulate a grand prix and the many challenges that they may face, improving the standard of officiating and training new figures.

 

Hamilton vs Verstappen

Lewis-Hamilton-and-Max-Verstappen-collide-at-the-2022-Brazilian-GP

Hamilton and Verstappen: still not giving way

Peter J Fox/Getty Images

The rivalry may have been paused in 2022 but the sense of injustice hasn’t gone away, whether it’s Max Verstappen facing endless questions about the legitimacy of the 2021 title, or Hamilton coming to terms with losing a record-breaking eighth championship in a sport where he knows there’s no guarantee that chance will come round again.

Related article

Although the pair have since rarely found themselves fighting for the big points, there was a flashback to the intense and contact-filled battles of 2021 in Sao Paulo in 2022 when battling for second. Once again, neither driver showed themselves willing to yield and they came together, dropping both down the field. “What can I say?” said Hamilton. “You know how it is with Max.”

“It’s just a shame,” said Verstappen. “I thought we could race quite well together but clearly the intention was not there to race.”

In the Motor Sport season review podcast, Mark Hughes pointed out how Verstappen’s battles with Leclerc this year had been cleaner; the Red Bull driver leaving his rival room. “That’s just not how he races Lewis,” said Hughes. “Lewis sometimes gives him room and sometimes thinks, ‘no’. It’s maybe not the wisest of choices that each of them makes.”

 

Dual race directors

Niels Wittich took charge for the final races of 2022

The FIA seemed to feel guilty about the workload that it had placed upon Masi who, along with officiating 22 races, was attending other events to learn from different series, checking new venues, as well as being the lightning rod for media and teams at grands prix.

So a two-person role was created for 2022, bringing in two respected names: Eduardo Freitas from WEC and Niels Wittich from DTM. The theory was fine, but when a recovery vehicle joined a soaking wet Suzuka circuit before all cars were behind the safety car, the rotation was stopped, amid apparent concerns over continuity.

Wittich remained for the rest of the races in 2022 and has been the sole race director in 2023.