Matt Bishop: 'Magnussen should say goodbye to F1 and enjoy victory elsewhere'

F1

Two F1 drivers were in the news last week: Matt Bishop explains why Kevin Magnussen, currently without a 2025 seat, should walk away from the world championship, and commends Ralf Schumacher for making the paddock a more welcoming place

Kevin Magnussen Haas 2024

Is 2024 Kevin Magnussen's final year in F1?

Getty Images

The most dramatic media narrative to come out of Sunday’s Hungarian Grand Prix was undoubtedly that provoked by the in-race team radio communications between Lando Norris and the McLaren pitwall. Such tensions are not of course new. Drivers’ shirty reactions to team orders have been a factor in motor sport for generations, and Norris complied with McLaren’s instruction in the end, so let’s not get carried away. Besides, once McLaren’s race strategists had decided to pit Norris first, so as to protect his second place from MercedesLewis Hamilton, who was running third, they were always going to leave themselves open to advantaging Lando so much that he would undercut and thereby get ahead of his team-mate Oscar Piastri; and, after that, to make things trickier still for the engineers squirming on the McLaren ‘prat perch’, Norris showed that he had the pace to win.

It was a bit of a mess but, as I say, we have seen many similar occurrences before, especially when a team has race-dominating pace. The difference in the 2020s is twofold: (1) team radio messages are instantly broadcast on the world TV feed, and (2) they immediately then become the subject of impassioned and protracted social media bickering. Imagine how today’s Twitter/X keyboard warriors would have reacted if social media had existed when at Monza in 1956 the handsome, dapper, charming, and popular 24-year-old Peter Collins, on the cusp of becoming the UK’s first Formula 1 world champion, instead handed his Lancia-Ferrari to his team leader Juan Manuel Fangio after Fangio had suffered a steering failure in the closing stages of the Italian Grand Prix, thereby gifting the F1 world title to a 45-year-old Argentine who had already won it three times.

Anyway, let’s move on. In the days leading up to Sunday, the dominant Hungarian Grand Prix media narratives had centred on two F1 drivers who were never going to be in contention for the win, one because his car was and is insufficiently competitive and the other because he retired from F1 17 years ago: I am referring to Kevin Magnussen and Ralf Schumacher.

Matt Bishop with Kevin Magnussen in 2022 Miami F1 paddock

Matt Bishop (right) with Magnussen in Miami, 2022

Grand Prix Photo

I know Kevin very well, having first met him in 2010 when, as a cocky 17-year-old, he was enrolled in the McLaren Driver Development Programme when I was the team’s communications director. He and I worked well together during the year in which he raced his single F1 season for us — 2014 — and we have remained pally ever since. We send each other WhatsApp messages frequently — sometimes about current F1 matters but just as often about Stirling Moss (his racing hero), Carlos Reutemann (my racing hero), Jim Clark (everyone’s racing hero), Ford Mustangs (his favourite American muscle car), Chevy Corvettes (my favourite American muscle car), Porsche 911s (a shared enthusiasm for us), and indeed life, love, sex, drugs, and roll ’n’ roll (not drugs actually). So it was that I was not surprised by his Haas team’s press statement on Thursday, announcing that he would not be a part of its 2025 driver line-up.

Related article

Even so, I was sad to read it, and I was touched by his plucky reaction when inevitably he was quizzed about it by the F1 media in the Hungaroring paddock: “Would I have liked to continue here [at Haas]? I think, you know, had I continued, it would have been cool to see, you know, the fruits of the momentum that’s been built here recently. That would’ve been interesting, but I think there’s also other interesting projects out there, and there’s still seats available in F1. So, right now, I think the best thing is just to focus on doing good races and being in contention for the seats available, and things will fall into place eventually.”

The following quote was included in the Haas press statement, attributed to team principal Ayao Komatsu: “I’m hoping we can find a way to keep working together in some capacity. We can hopefully define that in the near future, but his [Magnussen’s] extensive experience in F1 and his knowledge of our working operations are undoubtedly of value in our ongoing growth and development.”

Among the many drivers with whom I have worked in my long F1 career, Magnussen is without doubt the most passionately besotted with racing for racing’s sake. Moreover, having tried my best to cheer him up in what was for him an annus horribilis, 2015, when he was bored and frustrated in the role of McLaren’s F1 reserve driver, I fervently hope that he does not agree to take on the kind of quasi-managerial role to which Komatsu has apparently alluded. Let’s be blunt. Kevin is an old-school racer. As I say, his racing hero is Stirling Moss, who retired 30 years before he was born. Many times, over a coffee or a beer, I have held his rapt attention by reeling off the stories I know so well and love so much, about Antonio Ascari, Tazio Nuvolari, Achille Varzi, Bernd Rosemeyer, Rudolf Caracciola, B Bira, Alberto Ascari, Juan Manuel Fangio, Stirling Moss, Jim Clark, Graham Hill, Jackie Stewart, Jochen Rindt, Ronnie Peterson, James Hunt, Carlos Reutemann, Mario Andretti, Gilles Villeneuve, Ayrton Senna, Michael Schumacher, Mika Hakkinen, and many more. He absolutely loves all that. By contrast the only aspect of 21st-century F1 that he genuinely enjoys is the bit in the cockpit, even though he has raced a podium-worthy F1 car only once, in his first ever grand prix, since when he has started 175 more, the highlights being four fifth places.

Kevin Magnussen celebrates after finishing on the podium in 2014 Australian Grand Prix

Magnussen celebrates a podium on his grand prix debut

Grand Prix Photo

He is still only 31. It is not impossible that he will land himself an F1 drive for 2025, but it is unlikely. What he can do, and should therefore embrace doing instead, is to wave a fond farewell to F1 and set sail on the next voyage of his racing odyssey. Whether you be a driver, an engineer, a mechanic, a journalist, a photographer, a comms/PR exec, a marketer, or whatever, there really is life after F1, as I now know. It is difficult to see that truth when you are still immersed in F1’s gurgling cauldron, but a truth it is. The British Touring Car Championship is nowhere near as glamorous as F1, but the work that I do for my comms/PR agency requires me to attend the odd BTCC race, and I relish doing so. An old F1 saying has it that you meet a better class of person at the back of the grid. I would put it slightly differently: you meet a less remorselessly ruthless kind of person at the back of the grid. In the BTCC there is no such gradation. A piranha club the BTCC is not. To be clear, I am not, repeat not, tipping Magnussen as a future BTCC driver; no, I am saying that he will enjoy himself in a bright, carefree and uncomplicated way when next year he enters, and reminds himself of the pleasure of winning races in, whatever non-F1 series he selects.

And Ralf Schumacher? I know him far less well than I know Kevin Magnussen, although I have known Ralf for much longer. I took over the editorship of F1 Racing magazine in December 1996, which meant that the first F1 grand prix to be run in my 11-year spell in the editor’s chair was the 1997 Australian Grand Prix, which was Schumi Jr’s debut F1 race. I first met him at Imola seven weeks later, where I argued with him for the first time, our bone of contention being the arrangements for a photoshoot. I lost patience with him again six years later when, so unpublishably bland were his answers to my questions about his chances of winning the 2003 world championship for BMW-Williams that I excused myself and aborted our interview after 11 of our allotted 30 minutes. And, rather more (in)famously, I lost my temper with him altogether when, four years after that, at Indianapolis in 2007, by which time he was an unhappy albeit very well paid Toyota driver in the departure lounge of his F1 career, I swore at him when, again, he caused problems during a photoshoot. I regret that. It was rude of me.

The reason why he was suddenly a subject of media attention in Budapest last Thursday was that he had just come out as being in a same-sex relationship. I found his Instagram post very touching, for it was modest, generous, and loving: “The most beautiful thing in life is when you have the right partner by your side with whom you can share everything,” he wrote, the accompanying photograph an image of him with his arm around his partner, Etienne, looking out together at a calm and pretty seascape.

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Ralf Schumacher (@ralfschumacher_rsc)

The reaction from F1 drivers, F1 team principals, and indeed the whole F1 community, including media and fans, was overwhelmingly supportive. Granted, inevitably, a few bigots took to social media to spread a bit of homophobic poison, but I hope that neither Ralf nor Etienne was too upset by their rantings. As a gay man who has been ‘out’ in F1 circles for decades, I know all too well that reading homophobic insults is part and parcel of having a social media presence in F1. You get used to it, even though it still sometimes has the power to wound.

As Lewis Hamilton suggested in his typically wise and kind reaction to Schumacher’s announcement, the LGBTQ+ element of Ralf’s personality is unlikely to be a new discovery for him. Ralf is 49, after all. Moreover, as long as 25 years ago there were rumours rife in the F1 paddock about his sexuality — yet, despite the fact that journalists are often derided alongside politicians, bankers, lawyers, and estate agents as members of one of the least trusted professions, I feel proud of us as a collective to be able to state with confidence that the sexual scuttlebutt about Ralf never made its way into print in any reputable or mainstream F1 magazines or websites.

Nonetheless, back in the day, some F1 folk used to ask me silly questions about the subject, the daftest usually along the following lines: “How come you and Ralf don’t get on when you’re both gay?” Well, first of all, we did not and still do not know that Ralf is specifically gay per se. All we can accurately say is what he himself has revealed, which is that he is in a loving relationship with a man. I think we can state with safety that he is LGBTQ+ therefore. But it was a foolish question besides that: first, he was not ‘out’ at the time, and, second, our disagreements had nothing to do with either his sexual preferences or mine. Ralf was generally grumpy back then, truth be told, and I guess that may in part have been a result of the burden of secrecy he was carrying. But I do not know that.

Ralf Schumacher

In 180 starts, Schumacher scored 27 podium finishes, six pole positions and six race wins

Grand Prix Photo

I doubt that he now wants to become a trailblazer for LGBTQ+ rights, equality, and inclusion, and he does not have to be if he does not want to be. Nonetheless, his coming-out is important, because he is only the fourth driver in the 75-season history of F1 who we know to be or have been LGBTQ+, and he is the first to have publicly declared himself as such. Moreover, he was a successful F1 driver — a six-time grand prix winner no less — and his super-famous surname undeniably adds weight to his stature within the sport. (The other three F1 drivers whom we know to have been LGBTQ+ were Nicha Cabral, Mike Beuttler, and Lella Lombardi, who are all sadly no longer with us.)

Even if Ralf does not become an LGBTQ+ trailblazer, which as I say I do not expect him to, the act of his coming-out, and the hugely positive way in which his announcement was welcomed by F1 stars past and present, will inevitably have the effect of making more LGBTQ+ people, including young LGBTQ+ people, feel that they belong in F1 — as drivers, as engineers, as mechanics, as journalists, as photographers, as comms/PR execs, as marketers, and of course, last but very far from least, as fans. Or, to put it another way: if you can see it, you can be it.

Related article

When the Olympic diver Tom Daley came out as being in a relationship with a man in 2013, when he was just 19, his announcement was also very well received. Since then he has become a household name in the UK, as loved as much for his knitting as for his diving, but his initial act of coming-out had a profoundly positive effect. It made some young LGBTQ+ people who had feared that sport might not be for them realise that, on the contrary, it could be. Now, 11 years later, a larger percentage of male divers are LGBTQ+ than had been the case before Daley took his courageous coming-out step, and it may well be that there are young LGBTQ+ people who have seen and been heartened by Ralf’s similar announcement, and above all by the positive reaction to it from the drivers who race in F1 today, and will now embrace their enthusiasm for F1 with a confidence that perhaps they lacked before. As I say: if you can see it, you can be it.

It is my understanding that the current crop of 20 F1 drivers are all heterosexual. But if it so happens that there is a closeted LGBTQ+ driver in Formula 2, Formula 3, Formula 4, or any other feeder formula — and, to be clear, I am not saying that there is one — and if in a few years’ time he were to work his way up to F1, find himself a good drive, and do well, I hope that he would be able to look back at the warm and friendly way in which Schumacher’s quiet revelation had been greeted, and fling open his closet door with, yes, gay abandon.

Or let’s put it another way. Let’s fast-forward to a Sunday in late May 2029. You are watching an evening TV news bulletin and you hear the newscaster say the following words: “Today, in Monte-Carlo, the American driver Johnny Jenkins won the Monaco Grand Prix for Ferrari. Second was his team-mate Ollie Bearman from the UK, and third was Kimi Antonelli, from Italy, for Mercedes. Let’s go over to Monaco to hear what the winner had to say after his triumph.” And then let’s imagine that the next image on your TV screen was Jenkins, with his arm around his boyfriend, speaking an F1 version of what Tom Daley said when he won an Olympic diving gold medal in Tokyo in 2021. Here is what Daley said: “I feel incredibly proud to say that I’m a gay man and also an Olympic champion. When I was younger I didn’t think I’d ever achieve anything because of who I was. So to be an Olympic champion now just shows that you can achieve anything. I came out in 2013 and, when I was younger, I always felt I was the one who was alone and different and didn’t fit in. There was always going to be something about me that was never going to be as good as what society wanted me to be. So I hope that any young LGBTQ+ person out there can now see that, no matter how alone you may be feeling right now, you’re not alone. You can achieve anything.”

Well said and well done, Tom Daley. Well said and well done, Ralf Schumacher. Good luck in the future, Kevin Magnussen. Johnny Jenkins is a hypothetical character whom I have invented. Well, there was a racing driver called Johnny Jenkins, but he was born in Wales in 1875, he raced in the Indy 500 in 1912 and 1913, and he died in Texas in 1945. I am pretty sure that he was not LGBTQ+, and I am absolutely certain that he will not win the 2029 Monaco Grand Prix.

Matt Bishop is a Founder Ambassador of Racing Pride. If you would like to know more about the work that it does, click here: https://racingpride.com/