How Verstappen's talent misled Red Bull in F1 battle with Mercedes

F1

In 2020, Red Bull was struggling to get on terms with Mercedes, as Max Verstappen's ability to adapt sent it into a development dead-end, says Mark Hughes. Then a turnaround at the Abu Dhabi GP began its F1 domination...

Verstappen 2020

Talent can hurt in F1 — as Verstappen proved for Red Bull in 2020

Red Bull

Mark Hughes

As Max Verstappen completed the most statistically dominant F1 season of all time with another victory last weekend, around Abu Dhabi, it seems remarkable that just three years ago his race win here was only his tenth, having averaged 1.6 wins per season. He’s now on 54, having averaged 17 victories per season in the last two years.

That 2020 win came at the end of a season of total Mercedes domination and at the time it looked like just a slight stutter from Mercedes – it was running very tired power units and Lewis Hamilton was still recovering from Covid, having missed the previous race. In reality its source was a very significant breakthrough in understanding from Red Bull a few races earlier. One which laid the foundations for the domination which was to follow: competitive by the end of ’20, vying to be the fastest in ’21, dominant in ’22, dominant on a different scale in ’23.

“It’s been frustrating,” said technical director Pierre Wache at the end of 2020, “because if we’d understood earlier what we know now [Mercedes] were beatable.” It seemed a very brave claim given the level of domination Mercedes had displayed in that cobbled-together Covid season. But history suggests he was probably right. Verstappen’s straightforward victory in Abu Dhabi 2020 from a narrowly-won pole was foundational for all that was to come. It was the embodiment of a new level of aerodynamic understanding and control.

Max Verstappen Abu Dhabi 2020 Valtteri Bottas and Lewis Hamilton behind

Verstappen led from Bottas and Hamilton to claim his second victory of 2020

Red Bull

The 2020 RB16B was the first Red Bull to follow the Mercedes-inspired ‘narrow nose with cape’ concept and the team had completely re-engineered the front suspension to make it possible. In the low-rake Mercedes it had been a very fruitful concept over the previous three years. But in the high-rake Red Bull it made for an initially tricky car. The great slow corner agility could spill over into an uncontrollable rear with little warning. Alex Albon described it as “you just had to sneeze at it and it would spin.” Yet Verstappen found a way of being quick in it.

Related article

Ironically, a key reason why it had taken the team a while to fully uncover the potential of the 2020 car was Verstappen’s off-the-scale ability. He’d initially made it seem as if the development path they were on in the first part of the delayed season (it began in Austria in June rather than Melbourne in March) was a fruitful one. But it was a dead-end, one which they’d had to reverse out of from mid-season.

Initially, the more agile they were making the RB16B in slow corners, the faster Verstappen was going despite the deterioration in rear stability – and despite Albon in the second car being left further behind. That was the vital clue and when even Verstappen could find no more from it, it confirmed the set up direction had reached a dead-end.

Even with the sophistication of modern simulation tools, there’s no telling in advance just how far a new aerodynamic philosophy will take you when you embark upon it. The relative development potential of competing philosophies is not a knowable thing until it’s happening, until the track reality begins to reward or smack down the theories. Verstappen’s ability to derive lap time from quicker rotation into slow corners without losing time from the rear instability which comes as part of that had disguised where the most fruitful development path was. All the aerodynamic development parts which had been produced in those first few months of the season – and the set-up direction around them – had been heading the team down a cul-de-sac. Max had continued making lap time gains, but the gains were smaller than those being made by Mercedes. Once this was understood, it took several months to get the development programme turned around and heading in a different – ultimately more fruitful – direction. Only then were the gains made to Mercedes.

Verstappen trails Hamilton Bahrain 2020

Verstappen began his Hamilton challenge long before 2021’s visit to Bahrain

Red Bull

“We started 2020 not far off Mercedes,” recalled Wache at the time, “and we had a massive down in the middle of the season before coming up again. Clearly we went in the wrong direction and we recovered. That’s where we missed something in our analysis in terms of development direction. We identified that and what the driver could use as performance. We had some characteristics that made it very difficult to extract the theoretical performance from and what we identified after mid-season – this characteristic was the main limitation of the car and we moved away from it. At the end of the season we could confirm this and that gave us a good foundation for ’21.

“Max’s ability was a contributory cause to the problem we had. He has an ability to control this sort of instability that would be impossible for some others. We know that sometimes, making a car on the edge in this way can create a quicker car. You don’t realise you went too far in the wrong direction because you are extracting more lap time from the car. And that was only because he has so much talent.

Him having so much talent heightened the problem

“So you keep going in this direction but you go too far. After his feedback – and he gave us some help – you are in so competitive a situation and the system is so big, to revert to what you did is quite long and painful. It’s a big gain for him having so big a talent that he can set up the car with some rear instability and extract more performance from a given car. But also if we cannot give him a car that is not stable enough, it’s not good. It’s a shame, but him having so much talent heightened the problem.”

Through the different sets of regulations seen since 2020, Red Bull knows where home is in terms of aero balance. Even when it’s not initially had it – like at the beginning of 2022 – it knows where the ultimate trade-off is, and so where it needs to get to. Verstappen’s ideal window in the trade-off between instability and rotation has effectively directed the team’s development direction ever since the dawning realisation of mid-season 2020. Abu Dhabi three years ago was the first time it had defeated Mercedes on raw speed. It was the first crack in the dam.