Broken mirror brings bad luck in Qatar GP, but Verstappen rises supreme

F1

Max Verstappen was 'the complete package' at the 2024 Qatar Grand Prix, managing his tyres to victory. Everyone else, in one way or another, was affected by a rogue mirror, writes Mark Hughes

Verstappen 2024 Qatar grand prix

A ninth victory for Verstappen in Qatar

Red Bull

Mark Hughes

Max Verstappen’s victory was perfectly executed in keeping the pursuing Lando Norris at bay for 35 laps then cruising home after the McLaren driver was awarded a stop/go penalty for failing to slow for yellow flags.

The Red Bull driver had out-qualified everyone but had been awarded a one-place grid drop for impeding George Russell, even though both were on preparation laps. Russell’s testimony in the stewards’ room which led to him – and not Verstappen – starting from pole infuriated Verstappen. But it turned out the Mercedes driver wasn’t a threat to Max on race day, demoted down to third at the first corner and struggling for pace on degrading tyres thereafter.

It was the yellow flag which was the cause of the race’s big controversy. It was for the discarded mirror (from Alex Albon’s Williams) which lay on the pit straight. Verstappen saw the yellows and lifted. Norris didn’t. Because it’s a safety issue the penalty was unforgiving: a 10sec stop/go. It was even more brutal given that the pack had recently been compressed by two safety car periods as he took his penalty, so he rejoined last with just 13 laps to go. He recovered as far as 10th and was disconsolate afterwards, accepting the full blame as McLaren failed to take the constructors’ world title out of reach of Ferrari, for which Charles Leclerc took second place.

McLaren Ferrari 2024 Qatar Grand Prix

McLaren and Ferrari’s constructors’ title battle will go down to the wire

Getty Images

Six laps after the mirror landed on the track Valtteri Bottas ran over it, creating a debris site which is suspected to have been what punctured the front-lefts of Carlos Sainz and Lewis Hamilton. Which gave us the first safety car – the one in which Leclerc passed Oscar Piastri who was unluckily brought in the lap before – and then the related second one (for the beached cars of Sergio Perez and Nico Hülkenberg). Both Mercs had pitted well before Albon’s mirror came adrift, their front tyres worn out. Russell ended up a delayed fourth.

Related article

But why was the mirror left there? “I didn’t even know it was a mirror,” said Verstappen. “Of course, I saw [it] but we have done more races where there has been a bit of debris offline. So I guess it’s a bit of a tough call to make.”

“I think the right thing to do would have been a VSC or a safety car pretty much straight away,” said Piastri. “I didn’t really know where the mirror was, but after seeing it on the big screen, being basically in the braking zone for Turn 1 when you’re trying to overtake, I don’t really know what we were going to do until someone hit it, because I think having it sit there for 30 laps of the race would have been not very smart. So I think, yes, probably should have been a bit earlier because at racing speeds, especially in that part of the track, you can’t have a marshal run on and just simply pick it up. So maybe we could have been a bit quicker with that.”

“You can’t put a VSC out because the cars are not evenly spaced around the track,” said Russell, “And a safety car would perhaps been a bit too extreme. Not an easy decision.”

Lewis Hamilton 2024 Qatar Grand Prix puncture

Hamilton received multiple doses of bad luck on Sunday — his late puncture arguably being the most critical

Getty Images

The timing of the rogue mirror was unfortunate. It came as almost everyone was still on their original tyres (but not the tyre-eating Mercs), which by then were very worn. Hence the punctures. Pirelli’s Mario Isola gave further background to this. “This track has some peculiar characteristics. It’s very severe in terms of the energy exerted on the tyres and in terms of tread wear not leading to a drop in performance. This can create a situation in which wear levels reach their limit as the teams try to lengthen their stint as long as possible. Even in the sprint we saw some cars had 100% wear despite starting on a fuel load about a third of that in the Grand Prix. The left front is the most loaded tyre and it’s no coincidence both punctures were on this tyre. When you reach a certain level [of wear] even the smallest piece of debris can cause a situation like this.”

The incident altered the race’s outcome – good or bad – for everyone. Except Verstappen. Who was supreme throughout. “Max was just incredible in how he controlled Lando,” said an admiring Christian Horner. “All the time Lando was taking out of him was in the high-speed Turn 12, 13, 14 corners. Max was managing his tyres extremely well there which gave him the longevity and of the first four cars he was definitely in the best place with his tyres. The way he was keeping Lando out of DRS range despite managing the tyres was incredible. He had to get the gap at a certain point in the middle sector [to be safe at the detection point] and he hit that within 0.1sec every lap. The precision was unbelievable. That’s Max, he’s just the complete package.”