Why are modern MotoGP riders so inconsistent?

MotoGP

Today’s MotoGP riders can’t put together consistent championship campaigns like they used to. Why? Because if every single star in a rider’s firmament isn’t perfectly aligned on race day, he’s in hell

Miller Espargaro Marquez and Zarco in MotoGP battle

Jack Miller, Aleix Espargaró, Marc Márquez (out injured for six races), Johann Zarco and others have had very up and down 2022s

Dorna Sports

Mat Oxley

Top MotoGP riders are more inconsistent now than they’ve been ever before.

This understandably confuses a lot of fans and can make MotoGP impossible to understand: how can the same rider and motorcycle finish second one weekend and tenth the next? Was the rider just not bothered the second time out, so he decided to have a lazy Sunday? Did his engineers decide to take the weekend off and drink beers in the hotel bar?

There has to be a reason, so is it because today’s MotoGP riders are lazy, unfocused and too busy spending their millions on fast cars and swimming pools?

The results of recent seasons suggest that might be the case.

The entire top ten flashed past the chequered flag separated by five seconds in Qatar and Australia

In 2020 Joan Mir won the MotoGP title by scoring just 48% of the available points. Fabio Quartararo won last year’s crown with 62% of the points. Now Pecco Bagnaia is on the verge of winning this year’s championship, having scored 54% of the points from the first 19 races. This puts them all near the bottom of average points scores since the first world championship in 1949.

Compare these numbers to MotoGP kings of recent decades: Wayne Rainey won the 1990 title scoring 85% of the points, Mick Doohan took the 1997 crown on 90%, Valentino Rossi the 2003 championship on 89%, Casey Stoner the 2011 title on 82%, Jorge Lorenzo the 2015 crown on 73% and Marc Márquez the 2019 championship on 88% (the greatest premier-class campaign of all time, by the way, with spec tyres and electronics).

So surely today’s MotoGP winners must be a bit useless by comparison? Of course not. The exact opposite, in fact.

The fact is that Dorna’s machine-equalising technical regulations (from 81mm bore limits to spec tyres and unified electronics software) makes all the bikes perform pretty much the same. And the depth of talent and professionalism of all the riders has never been greater, so there are more riders capable of doing the lap times required to fight for the podium.

Start of MotoGP Sepang round

The start at Sepang on Sunday. Twice this year the top ten finishers have been separated by just five seconds

Dorna Sports

All this conspires to make the racing closer than it’s ever been. The two closest top-15 finishes in seven decades of premier-class racing were both achieved this year, in Qatar and Australia, where the entire top ten flashed past the chequered flag separated by five seconds. And MotoGP’s ten closest top-15 finishes have all been recorded since 2018!

Twenty-five years ago the 1997 Australian GP at Phillip Island had the top ten finishers separated by 36.8 seconds, a difference of 1.36 seconds per lap between the winner and the rider in tenth.

This year’s Phillip Island top ten was covered by 5.9 seconds, a lap-time difference of 0.22 seconds between winner Álex Rins and tenth-placed Brad Binder.

Related article

The tiny gadget that will transform MotoGP in 2023
MotoGP

The tiny gadget that will transform MotoGP in 2023

MotoGP’s minimum tyre pressure rules will be enforced for the first time in 2023, which will have a huge effect on the racing. For a start, top engineers believe there will be less overtaking and more crashes

By Mat Oxley

Of course, the fact that the racing is closer than ever means that if riders and engineers don’t get absolutely everything out of their bikes and tyres on Sunday afternoon they will end up nowhere.

If the correlation between rider talent and technique, tyre allocation, track layout and grip, temperature and weather, machine character and settings are an nth of a degree out then the rider who was on the podium last weekend will struggle to get inside the top ten next time out. The tiniest difference in performance, one or two tenths of a second – less than the blink of an eye – is all it takes to destroy a rider’s race.

Grand Prix racing didn’t use to be like this. If Alex Crivillé, who won the 1997 Australian GP, had been 0.22 seconds per lap slower he still would’ve finished a very comfortable third, 22 seconds ahead of the next rider home. Two Sundays ago that drop in performance would’ve put him way out of the championship points in 19th.

Such crazy-close racing has other consequences. Riders must risk everything on every lap if they want to be in the hunt for the podium, which inevitably means more crashes. Bagnaia is the perfect case in point here – he’s crashed out of five races this year and he’s leading the championship. No one’s ever done that before and it’s another sign of the times.

Jack Miller drinks champagne from his shoe after MotoGP win in Japan

Miller celebrates victory in Japan. At other races this year he’s struggled to get inside the points

Ducati

“It’s just the level of it, everyone is riding on such a highly strung level,” says factory Ducati rider Jack Miller, who has finished on the podium seven times so far this year and finished outside the top ten on four occasions. “To bring the amount of speed you need into each weekend to be competitive makes it a bit more difficult to be as consistent as maybe you were in the past, when you couldn’t be in the title fight if you had more than one DNF.

“The amount of good bikes and riders that are out there – if you have a bad day now you’re struggling to get points. At Mugello and Barcelona I had shit weekends, but I wasn’t that far off and I was fighting for two or three points. Whereas in the past when you had a bad weekend you were fourth or fifth, so you’d go into the next one and the bike would be back on [so] you wouldn’t have to override yourself. Nowadays you’ve got to really override yourself and that’s causing some inconsistency. So everything’s part of it: the level of the bikes, the level of the riders, the level of the championship and the number of races.”

“Maybe the younger riders thought that when the king is away the dogs will play”

Paul Trevathan, crew chief to KTM factory rider Miguel Oliveira, agrees and has own thoughts on the situation. First about Márquez’s absence from the front of the championship since he broke an arm at the first race of 2020.

“I think Marc had such a mental gain on everyone when he was dominating that the other guys almost thought they were racing for second,” he says. “The guy could do what he wanted. Then when he got hurt there was a new young generation coming in, who hadn’t been beaten up by him as much as the boys before, so maybe they thought that when the king is away the dogs will play. So they got better in their minds and all of sudden they had chances of winning and when you win you just get more and more confidence and it’s a snowball. There was no real leader in the class, so everyone was having a crack at it.”

Pecco Bagnaia crashes out of MotoGP Sachsenring round

Bagnaia slides off at Sachsenring, his fourth crash from the first ten races

Ducati

This has happened before. The 1999 and 2000 seasons were two of the closest in history because injury had forced Doohan to stop racing and Rossi was still getting up to speed on a 500.

“The second thing is the way we’ve developed the bikes, with the spec ECU and the single-tyre rules,” Trevathan adds. “Now we’ve all got a lot better at understanding the tyres and taking each concept as far as we can with that tyre. So you steal points. Other times we turn up at a race and things just don’t work and there’s no way that we’ve been able to turn it around. Yamaha has had those weekends, so has Ducati, so has everyone, where it’s nearly impossible.

From the archive

“It’s a case of tyre allocation and a combination of everything. I think it got even more like this when the new rear casing came out [Michelin’s new rear slick, which arrived in 2020]. Now there’s a lot more grip available and the compounds got softer, which some riders could handle and others couldn’t, like Valentino. The guys like him that needed a stiff casing, a solid feeling at the rear of the bike, not this squishy, big contact-patch thing, were in handcuffs, so they were finished.

“This changed things and then we changed the bikes a lot to get the most out of this tyre and because we’re all building up our experience we are all getting a lot better at it. So I think everyone is maximising everything out of the bike now and it’s brought everyone down to a level playing field.

“Before there was a tyre drop-off during races, while now it’s just a balls-out race from start to finish, as long as your tyres are working. Sure, you’ve got to manage different things. With a soft compound you’ve got to manage some bike movement, whereas with a hard compound you’ve got to manage the grip at the start of the race. But there’s not the big crossover point we had in the old days, when somebody would set up his bike to be stronger at the end of the race, like when [Andrea] Dovizioso was good with Márquez.

Miguel Oliveira celebrates MotoGP Malaysian victory with crew and family

Trevathan, to the left of Oliveira’s father, who is holding a drinks bottle, celebrates victory in Thailand.

Red Bull

“You remember the days of the ‘aliens’ [Rossi, Lorenzo, Márquez and so on]… If they had a bad day they were fourth or fifth, now you’re 15th. This is the reality. It’s also the way the boys are riding, how they’ve changed their styles and they’re all pure athletes and fully committed.

“I think the class has never been so stacked with talent. The will to win from the manufacturers and the riders has brought us into this era – it’s just a consequence of all that stuff.

“It can be really frustrating – you have a good race and you think, ‘What did we do different?’. Everyone is trying to drag everything out of the bike, but it’s milliseconds that make the difference now.

“Also, if the bike doesn’t work in FP1 you’re already on the back foot, because in FP2 you’ve got to throw in a soft tyre, so you’re qualifying already. Then FP3 is qualifying, then it’s Q1 and/or Q2, so you really need a package that is going to be in the ballpark when you turn up at a track. This helps a lot.

“It’s the same in races. Your rider runs wide and he drops five places and maybe he gets back a couple. But you can’t really catch up because there’s no slouches out there anymore.”

So, to sum up: any fans complaining about MotoGP riders being a bit useless because they can’t bring home big points hauls, week in, week out, don’t know what they’re talking about

 


MotoGP championship winners and leaders, by % points, 1949-2022

The 100 percenters

Year % of available points scored Rider Manufacturer
1959 100 John Surtees MV
1968 100 Giacomo Agostini MV

 

The 90 percenters

1994 90.57 Mick Doohan Honda
1997 90.67 Mick Doohan Honda

 

The 80 percenters

2003 89.25 Valentino Rossi Honda
2019 88.42 Marc Márquez Honda
1963 87.50 Mike Hailwood MV
2005 86.35 Valentino Rossi Yamaha
1958 85.71 John Surtees MV
2010 85.11 Jorge Lorenzo Yamaha
1990 85.00 Wayne Rainey Yamaha
1972 84.62 Giacomo Agostini MV
1986 84.24 Eddie Lawson Yamaha
1988 84.00 Eddie Lawson Yamaha
1969 83.33 Giacomo Agostini MV
2008 82.89 Valentino Rossi Yamaha
1996 82.40 Mick Doohan Honda
2011 82.35 Casey Stoner Honda
1960 82.14 John Surtees MV
2007 81.56 Casey Stoner Ducati
2001 81.25 Valentino Rossi Honda
2014 80.44 Marc Márquez Honda
1965 80.00 Mike Hailwood MV
1983 80.00 Freddie Spencer Honda
1991 80.00 Wayne Rainey Yamaha

 

The 70 percenters

1957 79.17 Libero Liberati MV
1987 79.11 Wayne Gardner Honda
1984 78.89 Eddie Lawson Yamaha
1985 78.33 Freddie Spencer Honda
2012 77.78 Jorge Lorenzo Yamaha
1964 77.77 Mike Hailwood MV
1995 76.31 Mick Doohan Honda
1989 76.00 Eddie Lawson Honda
1966 75.00 Giacomo Agostini MV
2013 74.22 Marc Márquez Honda
2015 73.33 Jorge Lorenzo Yamaha
1970 72.73 Giacomo Agostini MV
1971 72.73 Giacomo Agostini MV
1967 72.50 Giacomo Agostini MV
1980 72.50 Kenny Roberts Yamaha
2009 72.00 Valentino Rossi Yamaha
1954 71.87 Geoff Duke Gilera
2004 71.53 Valentino Rossi Yamaha
2018 71.33 Marc Márquez Honda
1993 70.86 Wayne Rainey Yamaha
1961 70.00 Gary Hocking MV

 

The 60 percenters

1998 69.33 Mick Doohan Honda
2002 66.75 Valentino Rossi Honda
1999 66.75 Alex Crivillé Honda
1978 66.67 Kenny Roberts Yamaha
2016 66.22 Marc Márquez Honda
2017 66.22 Marc Márquez Honda
1973 65.45 Phil Read MV
1977 64.85 Barry Sheene Suzuki
2000 64.50 Kenny Roberts Jr Suzuki
1981 63.64 Marco Lucchinelli Suzuki
1979 62.78 Kenny Roberts Yamaha
1962 62.50 Mike Hailwood MV
2021 61.77 Fabio Quartararo Yamaha
1974 61.33 Phil Read MV
1950 60.42 Umberto Masetti Gilera

 

The 50 percenters

1953 59.37 Geoff Duke Gilera
2006 59.29 Nicky Hayden Honda
1976 58.00 Barry Sheene Suzuki
1951 57.81 Geoff Duke Norton
1982 57.22 Franco Uncini Suzuki
1955 56.25 Geoff Duke Gilera
1975 56.00 Giacomo Agostini Yamaha
2022 54.31 Pecco Bagnaia Ducati (after 19 of 20 races)
1992 53.85 Wayne Rainey Yamaha
1949 51.66 Les Graham AJS
1956 50.00 John Surtees MV

 

The 40 percenters

2020 48.85 Joan Mir Suzuki
1952 43.75 Umberto Masetti Gilera

 

You may also like